Seat Belt Laws
(Last updated 05/20/2004)



There is much afoot lately regarding seat belt laws, much of which has been instigated by a recent bill passed by congress called the National Highway Safety Act of 2003 (S. 1993).  Here's the jist of it.  This bill requires of all 50 states in the Union to either get their seat belt usage up to, or above, 90% or else pass a primary enforcement law for their state.  They have 3 years to comply with this law.  The penalty?  Loss of Federal highway funding of up to 4%.  From where I come from, that's called blackmail and bully tactics.

For those that don't understand the phrase "primary enforcement law," let me explain as I didn't understand it at first either and it is a very important phrase.  In Kansas and several other states, there are seat belt laws in place, but they aren't violations an officer can pull you over for on their own.  That is called a "secondary enforcement law."  If the seat belt laws are made into primary enforcement laws, however, then an officer can pull you over just for that.

That's the short and sweet of it all.  Now, on with all the guts.  Here is a copy of the bill that was passed.  I pulled a copy of it from the database on www.senate.gov.  Search for the string "National Highway Safety Act of 2003" if you'd like to look it up there yourself.

I have several links below of various articles sorted by opposition, coverage of both sides, and pro-law.  Many of the opposition links are very good.  All of the pro-law stuff reads exactly the same, however.  There's a reason for that.  It's called propaganda.  The only thing preached is "save lives", "save lives" and lots of numbers.  For the people out there that really think this is all about "saving lives", they have a savior complex and they need to get over it and mind their own business in a free society.  As for the numbers, they loosely agree with each other.  All I could think of by the time I got through all of it was the old saying "figures lie and liars figure."  All the numbers are from polls and study groups.  People need to start realizing that they are not statistics; they are real people with independent thought and a way of life of their own.  To allow someone else to dictact your way of life is to loose your life.

This brings me to yet another subject this goes hand-in-hand with -- our freedom.  This subject is lengthy enough, of course, it constituted an entirely separate document.  Please click here to read it.

Once I get it written, you'll be able to review this document I compiled of all of my favorite quotes I found in all of the below documents that struck me as being the most interesting and profound opposition to seat belt laws -- people after my own heart.  :)


Opposition links

Vagaries of seat-belt law a pain in the neck
A columnist's excellent article against mandatory seat belts laws.  He says to himself at one point "Why, he asked, can't he just live his life?"
Seat Belt Law Endangers Innocents
"High observed usage does not guarantee a lower death rate."  "This law is not just about seat belts..."
Dangerous Changes in Seat Belt Law
Excellent points made based on American Colonial History.
The Fraud of Seat-Belt Laws
Excellent.  Very interesting opposition statistics in there too.
www.philipkdickfans.com -- Discussion group -- Re: Seat Belt Law Opposition Sites
This one has excellent comments from people.  Particularly read the entry from "Author: Bill Holdorf, Date: 05-05-04 20:14".  "All seat belt laws should be repealed in order to restore true liberty in the U.S."



Coverage of both sides and Law news articles

States that have Primary Enforcement Seat Belt Laws
List of states that have Primary Enforcement Seat Belt Laws (Kansas isn't one of them)


Pro-law

Senate pushes seat belt law Gives insight into what is really driving this! -- National Highway Safety Act of 2003 (S. 1993).
Senators Warner and Clinton Introduce Legislation to Enact National Primary Enforcement Seat Belt Law
From "Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety".  "An estimated $26 billion is spent annually on medical and emergency response care, lost productivity and..."
Deleware Click It or Ticket
"It is important to remember that driving is not a "right" but a privilege granted and controlled by the State of Delaware."  (I suppose somebody had to bring that up sooner or later as a lever).